Middlebury, VT | 434 East Main Street

$420,000
MLS#: 5114781
2,429
Sq Ft
1
Acres
2
Baths
4
Bedrooms
Restore Properties
Located in the heart of Middlebury, this home has been thoughtfully updated and improved upon by the current owners, turn-key ready for its next owner. This is a ranch style home, perfect for single-floor living. With new Quartz kitchen countertops, new appliances, new kitchen sink, and new flooring, the kitchen that once was divided by a wall now generously opens up to the living room, where a wood burning fireplace invites cozy nights. New insulation in the living room wall keeps the house warm, while a new mini-split allows cooler summers. A sweet sunroom has been finished to be year-round space with new energy efficient windows, insulation, walls and floors, and will be your favorite spot to hang out. The sunroom overlooks the spacious backyard, privately enclosed by evergreens. Down the hall are three bedrooms, all complete with new flooring. New lighting fixtures and new ceilings to eliminate popcorn were installed throughout the first floor. A full bath has two sinks, a bathtub, and stone tile detailing. Laundry is conveniently on the same floor. The finished lower level is perfect for games, office space, or additional family room. A 1/2 bath on this floor is handy, and a laundry hook-up is available. Located in the sought after Buttolph acres neighborhood, the half an acre lot allows plenty of space for gardening, pets, and outdoor enjoyment. You can easily walk to grocery stores, recreational facilities, multiple TAM trails, shops and all that Middlebury has to offer!
Set on 10 private acres, this charming log home offers the perfect balance of privacy, open lawn, and wooded surroundings, creating a peaceful Vermont retreat just 10 minutes from downtown Middlebury. Inside, the warm wood interior, high ceilings, and skylights fill the home with an abundance of natural light, creating a bright and inviting atmosphere throughout. The open-concept living room, dining area, and kitchen flow seamlessly together, making the home ideal for both everyday living and entertaining. With two bedrooms one on each level, and a three-quarter bathroom on each floor, the thoughtfully designed layout provides privacy and convenience. First-floor laundry is tucked neatly into the bathroom, while the spacious landing at the top of the stairs offers flexible space for a home office, reading nook, workout area, or hobby room. The full insulated basement provides exceptional storage with the potential to suit a variety of future needs. Outside, the property features a beautiful mix of open land and woods, offering endless opportunities for gardening, recreation, hobby farming, or simply enjoying Vermont's natural beauty. A classic barn adds both character and practical storage, while the large covered front porch and concrete patio create the perfect spaces to relax, entertain, or take in the peaceful surroundings. Combining rustic charm with everyday functionality, this inviting property offers the privacy of country living while remaining just minutes from the shops, restaurants, and amenities of downtown Middlebury.
This updated mid-century home features new flooring and fresh interior paint. Step outside onto the new back deck, the perfect place to entertain, relax, and take in views of your own private slice of Vermont. Set on 1.1 acres, the property offers plenty of space for a vegetable garden and complements the existing perennial plantings. The spacious home is conveniently located just minutes from Middlebury College, Porter Medical Center, and the Middlebury Natural Foods Co-op, while Burlington International Airport is only 52 minutes away. The oversized two-car garage provides ample room for vehicles, hobbies, and storage, with an additional separate workshop or storage area located at the rear. Outdoor enthusiasts will also appreciate the home's close proximity to several walking trails and recreation opportunities.
The Middlebury River is your backyard! Lovingly held by the same family for 60 years, this rambling Cape sits on a level, south-facing acre with approximately 140 feet of river frontage. Enjoy the soothing sounds of the river, mature shade, and a welcoming, walkable community. The front deck offers another spot to relax outdoors. The easily accessible main level features approximately 2,000 square feet, including a sunny kitchen with a newer quartz-topped island, cooktop, and dishwasher, plus a charming pantry with sink, refrigerator, and workspace. The kitchen opens to a dining room with built-ins. The living room features wide pine floors and a newer glass-front woodstove. Two spacious bedrooms, a renovated primary bath with walk-in shower, a second full bath, laundry, office, and sewing room complete the main floor. Upstairs, two additional rooms await updating and offer possibilities for bedrooms, studio space, or storage. The attached two-car garage includes additional space for hobbies or a workshop. Updates include a newer roof, windows, Buderus boiler, and circuit breakers. Conveniently located across from the Sarah Partridge Library, tennis courts, and recreation park, and within walking distance of the historic Waybury Inn and a convenience store. A special opportunity to enjoy riverside living with village amenities close at hand!The generous one-acre lot may offer potential for subdivision, subject to official town approval and all applicable requirements.
Welcome to your next home,10 Case Street, a charming 3-bedroom, 2-bath home dating back to 1840. Filled with character and warmth, this home features beautiful wood floors and the timeless appeal of an older Vermont property. Outside, there is plenty of garden space to create your own outdoor retreat, whether you envision flower gardens, vegetables, entertaining areas, or simply a peaceful place to enjoy the seasons. Conveniently located in East Middlebury, this home is just a short distance from the post office, gas station, and the historic Waybury Inn, making everyday errands and local amenities easily accessible. Enjoy the close-knit feel of East Middlebury while being just minutes from everything Middlebury has to offer. A wonderful opportunity to own a historic Vermont home with character, usable outdoor space, and a convenient location!
Enjoy easy living in this sunny, light-filled end-unit condo at Overbrook! With a comfortable two-bedroom layout, primarily single-level living, and a partially finished basement offering extra flexibility, this home makes the most of its space. The unfinished portion of the basement, along with generous closet space, provides plenty of room for storage. All-electric living means no fossil fuels for heating, cooling, or cooking, while the southern exposure brings in plenty of natural light. Located at the south end of the neighborhood, this unit also enjoys an open view across an expansive lawn, adding a welcome sense of space and greenery. Sidewalks connect you to the surrounding neighborhood and make it easy to head into downtown Middlebury for shopping, dining, and local events. The town pool, tennis and pickleball courts, and access to the 17+ mile Trail Around Middlebury are all nearby, making it easy to enjoy the outdoors and an active lifestyle. A bright, practical home in a convenient Middlebury location, this is an opportunity worth exploring sooner rather than later.
Set on a picturesque 1.1-acre corner lot with a country feel, this beautifully maintained 1800s home offers the perfect blend of historic character, thoughtful updates, and exceptional versatility. The spacious, renovated eat-in kitchen serves as the heart of the home, featuring custom cabinetry, stainless-steel appliances, and plenty of room for gathering. The first floor also offers a generous living room with a wood stove and direct access to the backyard. A full bathroom with laundry hookups and a den with a fireplace complete the main level. Recently remodeled, the den could easily serve as a home office, formal sitting room, or playroom. Upstairs, you’ll find three bedrooms, including a spacious primary bedroom with an adjoining bonus room already equipped with plumbing beneath the floor. This flexible space offers the opportunity to create a dream walk-in closet, private nursery, home office, or future en suite bathroom. A second laundry area and three-quarter bathroom complete the upper level. Major improvements completed within the past eight years include a new roof, water heater, front deck, and extensive landscaping that has transformed the yard into a more functional outdoor space. The possibilities continue with an impressive collection of outbuildings. The attached garage offers space for three or more vehicles while still leaving room for storage or a workshop. A detached one-car garage and an additional barn with room for two more vehicles, multiple storage areas, hobby space, or potential home-business use provide incredible flexibility. Enjoy a country setting while remaining only 10 minutes from Middlebury College, Porter Medical Center, downtown Middlebury, local restaurants, shops, schools, and everyday amenities. Whether you’re looking for room to grow, space to work from home, extensive garage and workshop space, or a historic Middlebury property with endless potential, this one-of-a-kind home is ready to welcome its next owners.

© 2026 Northern New England Real Estate Network, Inc. All rights reserved. This information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the IDX Program of NNEREN. Subject to errors, omissions, prior sale, change or withdrawal without notice.